McAfee has come a long way since his infamous swim in the Broad Ripple Canal years ago. The Colts punter has jumped onto the stand-up comedy scene — he’s got some A+ stories — with a bang, coming in a close second in that category this year. He’s also darn good at his day job, earning a Pro Bowl spot during the 2014 season. Safe to say he’s stayed true to his nickname Boomstick.
2nd: Andrew Luck
3rd: Tamika Catchings